A break from books…certain ones anyway
I haven’t done much reading this holiday, in fact I really haven’t done any! Sure I have read the odd blog, newspaper story, and recipe, but no books.
So today I sat down (on the last day of my holiday no less) to read Shane Claiborne’s book called the irresistible revolution. I read 2 pages, skimmed the chapter, skimmed the book and decided I wasn’t reading another on of “these.” What do I mean by these? Well, this book was another one of those “I grew up in church, got converted a million times, was conservative, went charismatic, went on a mission trip, found God, got back and left God, went back to a conservative church, went on staff, realized I was “postmodern” left church staff (remembering to mention how I did it with no money, and a big family), church planted, and now wrote a book. Of course not to forget to mention the ongoing wrestling of why they felt like a round peg in a square hole.” And have the audacity to tell me why I should change too!
Anyway, that is not a fair assessment of Shane’s book, and I am not critiquing him (I never read his book), but I have read way to many of “these” books, and every time realizing that the people I connect with and even my own story doesn’t resemble any of these stories!
Last Thursday I met up with Pernell Goodyear from the FRWY and in passing he made a comment about not reading as much anymore and through that has found that he has come up with an idea or concept for his community without it being overly inspired by “the ways other have done or said it should be done” and I am really connecting with that.
I love reading and my wonderful Mother-In-Law bought me a bunch of new books from my wish list this Christmas, but my reading list is going to change. I am going to read more in areas that interest me outside of the “testimonial church planting” kind and develop a wider educational discipline.
Here’s to 2007, predictions and my ongoing rants.

I think you are right that we have to be careful not to try and clone the experience of others. We need to discover for ourselves the nature and direction of our calling as individuals and communities. So great thoughts in that regard.
I would so, however, that the testimonials of other faith communities is one of the oldest traditions in our faiths history. Most of Scripture is the narrative record of God moving through history from which we can learn, understand and grow. Again, it is not that we should try to copy what they have done or even measure ourselves against their standard, but rather recognize that we are One Body who lessons must be collectively learned.
In regards to Shane’s book, it can be a frustrating read at points, but well worth it. I am not sure, by your definition, if it is in fact one of “these” books. Just my take. Happy New Year!
Peace,
Jamie
thanks Jamie, great point about the testimonials being important traditions. I think I am just tired of reading them…and reading many that are not as relevant to my context…it sure would be nice to have more for canada, i guess that’s why i read blogs
I hope to read the Claiborne book in the future, but more in the distant.